Graduate Studies Representative on Doctoral Exam Committees
To define the conditions that a Graduate Faculty member may serve as the Graduate Studies representative on a doctoral student examination committee
Doctoral student oral examinations include the doctoral comprehensive oral exam and the doctoral final oral exam (i.e., dissertation defense). The committee for the comprehensive oral examination and final oral examination must consist of at least five Graduate Faculty members appointed by the committee chair, department, and/or Graduate Division of the professional school/College.
The Graduate Studies representative must be a member of the Graduate Faculty with regular or dissertation status from a department other than the aspirant’s major department.
A faculty member from a different department with a courtesy appointment in the student’s department may serve as the Graduate Studies representative or in fulfillment of the committee majority pursuant of the Doctoral Student Oral Exam Committee Composition policy, but cannot serve in both roles at the same time.
The role of the Graduate Studies representative is designed to assure the appropriate standard of fairness, professionalism, judgment, and skill are applied throughout the examination process for the benefit of the institution and in the best interest of the student. As an independent participant observer, this member should have no personal or professional duality/conflict of interest with other members of the committee or the student that would prevent the representative from the unbiased fulfillment of these responsibilities (also see definitions section below for more information).
The Graduate Studies representative is a voting member of the committee and has full rights to participate in the examination. In the case of any unsatisfactory or irregular aspects of the exam or violation of Graduate Studies policy, the Graduate Studies representative shall provide a written report to the Dean of Graduate Studies for consideration of further action.
Before the examination, the Graduate Division should provide a list of responsibilities to the Graduate Studies representative. A list of these responsibilities is provided below:
- The examination was conducted in compliance with the policies and by-laws of Graduate Studies and the program’s Graduate Division.
- The examination was held in a manner that was free and open to the public.
- The representative was accorded full participatory rights in the examination.
- The representative was accorded full voting rights as a member of the committee.
- The examination was free from irregularities or unfairness to the student.
- The examination was free from irregularities or unfairness among faculty members.
- The examination, if repeated, occurred at least 90 days after last unsuccessful attempt.
Graduate Studies will manage any exceptions to the policy outlined above. Requests for exceptions must be made in writing to the Dean of Graduate Studies detailing the exception requested and the extraordinary circumstances that have resulted in the request.
07/08/2016: Updated to remove gendered pronouns.
12/03/2015: Technical edits.
10/1/2014: Graduate Studies made minor edits to the list of responsibilities of the Graduate Studies representative.
09/25/2014: Fixed broken links and made minor updates to formatting.
09/24/2014: This policy that specifically applies to the Graduate Studies representative on doctoral exam committees was developed from the preceding policy titled: Graduate Student Oral Exam Committee Composition. The Graduate Studies representative was formerly referred to as the “Outside committee member”. Prior to final approval by the Senior Vice Provost for Academic Affairs, this policy was reviewed and endorsed by the academic deans and associate deans, directors of graduate study, school personnel, the Executive Committee of Graduate Faculty, and the Dean of Graduate Studies.
03/01/2012: The Office of the Provost approved Graduate Student Oral Exam Committee Composition policy.